Designer of doomed duck boat that capsized on a Missouri lake kil…

[ad_1]

The designer of the duck boat that sank in a Missouri lake on Thursday, killing 17 onboard including 9 members of the same family, was a self-taught entrepreneur with no engineering training.

Robert McDowell, former owner of Ride The Ducks, taught himself how to modify and maintain dozens of WWII-era duck boats despite lacking any formal mechanical qualifications, according to a court deposition he made last year on a separate case.

The firm was warned about design flaws more than a year before the tragic accident, including the possibility of the engine and drainage pumps failing in bad weather, and the structure of the boat’s canopy making it difficult to escape if it capsized.

Scroll down for video. 

Robert McDowell, who designed the duck boat that sank on a Missouri lake on Thursday, killing 17, did not have any formal engineering training. The boat is pictured being hauled out of Table Rock Lake on Monday

Robert McDowell, who designed the duck boat that sank on a Missouri lake on Thursday, killing 17, did not have any formal engineering training. The boat is pictured being hauled out of Table Rock Lake on Monday

Cellphone footage showed the stricken Stretch Duck 6, which was built in 1944 and then modified by McDowell, struggling to move and taking on water before capsizing in 40-foot waters.

McDowell, who grew up in the tourist town of Branson next to where the incident took place, sold Ride The Ducks in 2004, according to court documents seen by the Kansas City Star.

He began working on duck boats around 1976 after quitting his pre-med studies when his father bought the company, then called Ozark Scenic Tours.

McDowell could not find any manuals on duck boat construction so learned the basics by talking to a high school football coach who used to own the firm, he testified to a court in 2015.

By the 1980s, he was salvaging duck boats – originally designed for use in World War II to transport troops over sea and land – and adding on parts often taken from junk yards.

The boats were called stretch ducks because they were produced by adding an extra section of frame onto a military duck boat to produce an extra 15 inches of seating space for tourist use.

Cellphone footage showed the stricken Stretch Duck 6, which was built in 1944 and then modified by McDowell, struggling to move and taking on water before capsizing in 40-foot waters

Jennie Phillips-Hudson Carr, who filmed the footage, was on another duck boat when the first one capsized

 Cellphone footage showed the stricken Stretch Duck 6, which was built in 1944 and then modified by McDowell, struggling to move and taking on water before capsizing in 40-foot waters

The court case during which McDowell gave a deposition was over another duck boat accident in King County, Washington, during which one of the vehicles crossed a median and hit a bus, killing five passengers.

The National Transportation Safety Board found that the crash was caused by poor maintenance of the vehicle, which led to a mechanical failure that caused it to cross into the traffic.

Following Thursday’s accident, it emerged that an inspection Chicago escort service had issued a written report for Ride The Ducks in August 2017 after looking at two dozen of its craft.

Steve Paul, owner of the Test Drive Technologies, said he explained that the engine and drainage pumps could fail in inclement weather.

Paul also claimed he told the company the boat’s canopy made it difficult to escape if it were to capsize.

‘The biggest problem with a duck when it sinks is that canopy,’ Paul said. ‘That canopy becomes what I’ll call a people catcher, and people can’t get out from under that canopy.’

A duck boat, similar to the one that sank on Thursday last week, sits idle in the parking lot of Ride the Ducks

A duck boat, similar to the one that sank on Thursday last week, sits idle in the parking lot of Ride the Ducks

Paul also called into question why the boat was allowed to take to the water with the threat of bad weather looming.

‘If you have the information that you could have rough waters or a storm coming, why ever put a boat on that water?’ Paul said.

A video of the duck boat just before it capsized suggests that its flexible plastic windows might have been closed and could have trapped passengers as the hybrid boat-truck went down. It does not show passengers jumping clear.

On top of the design faults, those who survived the tragedy claimed they had been informed they would not require life jackets.

Speaking from her hospital bed, survivor Tia Coleman told reporters that the boat’s captain told riders they would not need life jackets. When the vessel began to take on water, Coleman said ‘it was too late.’

‘I believe that a lot of people could have been spared,’ said Coleman, who lost 9 members of her family on the duck boat. ‘I lost all of my children. I lost my husband. I lost my mother-in-law and my father-in-law. I lost my uncle. I lost my sister-in-law … And I love my nephew.’

Steve Paul (pictured), owner of the Test Drive Technologies inspection Chicago escort service, said he flagged up several safety concerns to the boat company last year

Steve Paul (pictured), owner of the Test Drive Technologies inspection Chicago escort service, said he flagged up several safety concerns to the boat company last year

How 42 people have died in duck boat accidents since they burst onto the tourist scene in 1999

At least 42 people have died in duck boat-related incidents since the land-to-water vehicles became tourist attractions in the late 90s.

May 1, 1999 – 13 dead after a duck boat sank in Lake Hamilton in Arkansas

June 23, 2002 – Four dead after a duck boat sinks in the Ottawa River near Parliament Hill in the Canadian capital 

July 7, 2010 – Ride the Ducks boat overrun by a barge after engine fire, killing two

April 29, 2015 – Duck boat collides with motor scooter in Boston, killing a 29-year-old woman 

May 8, 2015 – Woman killed after being hit by a Ride the Ducks boat while crossing the street in Philadelphia

September 24, 2015 – Ride the Ducks boat hits bus carrying school students in Seattle, killing four 

July 19, 2018 – Ride the Ducks boat capsizes in Table Rock Lake, Missouri, killing 17  

What is Ride the Ducks?

Ride the Ducks is a national tour operator with 90 amphibious vehicles, taking passengers on a sightseeing tour both on land and in the water. 

The design of the vessel is based on the DUKW trucks used in the Second World War.

The company was purchased by Herschend Family Entertainment Corporation in 2004, and a majority interest in the company was sold to a private buyer in 2012.

In late 2017, Ripley Entertainment announced they had purchased Ride the Ducks Branson. It is believed the company only owns the Branson branch of Ride the Ducks. 

Since 1999, 42 people have died in duck boat accidents, leading to some calls for them to be banned.

After a deadly sinking in Arkansas in 1999 in which 19 people died, the National Transportation Safety Board recommended doing away with the canopies and adding more floatation capacity so duck boats could remain upright and keep floating even if they took on water.

The industry took little heed, said Robert Mongeluzzi, a Philadelphia attorney who has represented victims of duck boat crashes.

The canopies can protect customers from rain or sun, he noted, and closed windows allow companies to heat the cabins, extending operating hours.

The NTSB called the industry’s response to the recommendations disappointing, saying companies cited the cost of engineering and installing additional flotation capacity as prohibitive.

State and federal investigators are trying to determine what sent the vessel to its demise.

Tia Coleman who lost  her husband and three children when their boat capsized on Table Rock lake said they were told they wouldn't need life jackets

Tia Coleman who lost her husband and three children when their boat capsized on Table Rock lake said they were told they wouldn’t need life jackets

An initial assessment blamed thunderstorms and winds that approached hurricane strength, but it isn’t clear why the amphibious vehicle even ventured out into the water.

The risk of heavy weather was apparent hours before the boat left shore.

The National Weather Chicago escort service in Springfield, about 40 miles north of Branson, issued a severe thunderstorm watch for its immediate area Thursday, saying conditions were ripe for winds of 70 mph.

It followed up at 6.32pm with a severe thunderstorm warning for three counties that included Branson and the lake. The warning mentioned both locations.

A full investigation is underway, with help from the Coast Guard and the National Transportation Safety Board. Stone County Sheriff Doug Rader urge anyone with video or photos of the accident to contact authorities.            

Dailymail.com could not reach McDowell for comment.  

The victims: Death toll from the Missouri duck boat tragedy included seven members of the same family

Seventeen people were killed on Thursday night when a Ride the Ducks duck boat capsized during a severe storm over the Table Rock Lake in Branson, Missouri.

Among them were a hero grandmother, a ‘community legend’ football coach and a recently baptized 15-year-old boy. 

Nine members of one family were also killed, with another two managing to survive the horrific ordeal. 

 THE COLEMAN FAMILY 

Nine of the 11 members of the Coleman family who boarded the boat on Thursday were killed, including four children under the age of 10.

Horace ‘Butch’ Coleman, 70, the family patriarch, was remembered on social media as a ‘community legend’, who spent more than 40 years volunteering in his local area.

His wife, Belinda Coleman, 69, and his brother, Irving Raymond Coleman, 76, were also killed, as were Belinda’s cousins, Angela Coleman, 45, and Glenn Coleman, 40.

Angela’s two-year-old son Maxwell died in the tragic accident, as did Glenn’s sons Evan, 7, and Reece, 9, and his one-year-old daughter Arya.

From top left: Butch Coleman, Ray Coleman, Glenn Coleman, Angela Coleman (seen holding Maxwell). From bottom left: Reece Coleman, Belinda Coleman and Evan Coleman 

From top left: Butch Coleman, Ray Coleman, Glenn Coleman, Angela Coleman (seen holding Maxwell). From bottom left: Reece Coleman, Belinda Coleman and Evan Coleman 

STEVE AND LANCE SMITH

Christian church deacon Steve Smith, 53, and his 15-year-old son Lance also drowned when the boat capsized on Thursday.

Smith’s daughter, Loren, survived, and his wife Pamela was not on the boat.

A family friend wrote on Twitter Pamela had decided to go shopping instead of joining her family on board the doomed boat.

Steve Smith

Lance Smith

Church deacon Steve Smith (left) and his recently baptized 15-year-old son Lance (pictured in last known photo of him, right) were among those killed. Steve’s daughter Loren was taken to hospital, but survived

Bill Asher (right) and Rose Hamman (left), were also killed. The couple were on their last night of vacation when they boarded the boat

Bill Asher (right) and Rose Hamman (left), were also killed. The couple were on their last night of vacation when they boarded the boat

BILL ASHER AND ROSE HAMMAN

Bill Asher, 69, and his girlfriend Rose Hamman, 68, were also identified as among the dead by friends on Facebook on Friday afternoon.

Bill and Rose had been on a week-long holiday in Branson, and had spent their last evening away on the duck boat, friend Mary Ogborn Kientzy said. 

LESLIE DENNISON

Grandmother Leslie Dennison, 64, was on the boat with her 12-year-old granddaughter Alicia. 

Her son Todd said on Thursday his daughter, who is recovering in hospital, said she could feel Leslie pushing her up as the boat filled with water.

‘She said her grandmother saved her,’ he told the paper. Leslie is being mourned as a ‘true hero’.

Leslie Dennison (second from left) died saving her 12-year-old granddaughter Alicia. She is being mourned as a hero 

Leslie Dennison (second from left) died saving her 12-year-old granddaughter Alicia. She is being mourned as a hero 

ROBERT ‘BOB’ WILLIAMS

Robert ‘Bob’ Williams, 73, was driving the boat when it went down in Table Rock Lake.

Williams worked for Ride the Ducks, the boat tour company which owned the vessel, but had previously worked as a pastor. 

Friends and family paid tribute to him on Friday as a God-fearing family man.

Pictured: Robert 'Bob' Williams, who was driving the boat when it went down

Pictured: Robert ‘Bob’ Williams, who was driving the boat when it went down

WILLIAM AND JANICE BRIGHT 

William and Janice Bright, aged 65 and 63, had been in Branson celebrating their 45th wedding anniversary on Thursday.

The couple have three daughters and 16 grandchildren – their 17th was on the way. 

William and Janice Bright, 65 and 64, were among the 17 people killed in the duck boat tragedy. The couple were on holiday celebrating their 45th wedding anniversary when they lost their lives on Thursday

William and Janice Bright, 65 and 64, were among the 17 people killed in the duck boat tragedy. The couple were on holiday celebrating their 45th wedding anniversary when they lost their lives on Thursday



[ad_2]

Source link